Hawke Consulting
Free IT assessment
Menu
Home / Articles / Professional services
Professional servicesBasic5 min readNovember 2026

Your backup is only a backup if you've seen it restore

"The job says it ran" is not the same as "I got the file back."

Everyday filesBackup copySeparate loginevery nightRestore test: doneLast month, timed, written downRestore test: never"It says the job ran." Not proof.

Ask your office when the backup was last tested.

If the answer involves the phrase "I think it was when we switched providers," you have your answer.

What insurers expect a backup to be

The Hummel Group's 2026 write-up on cyber insurance requirements says carriers expect backups to be separated from the primary network, either air-gapped or in the cloud with separate credentials, protected by passwords and multi-factor sign-in, and tested regularly. It adds that carriers often prefer more than one backup method.

Attackers know backups exist, and some go looking for them. A copy that uses the same login as everything else can be encrypted along with the rest. And since phishing is still the top way in, per IBM's 2026 report, assume someone will eventually click.

Three ways a backup quietly fails

Same login as everything else. One stolen password reaches the files and the copy.

Nobody reads the report. The job has said "completed with warnings" for fourteen months.

It's never been restored. You don't know if it contains what you think, or how long a full restore would take. Finding out during an outage is the worst possible classroom.

A restore test in an afternoon

Pick one folder and one mailbox. Restore them to a different machine, not over the live copy. Time it. Open the files. Write down the date, who did it, and how long it took. That page is your evidence for the insurer and for yourself.

Then ask the bigger question: if the whole office were gone, how long until people could work? If the honest answer is "I don't know," that's your next project.

What "good enough" looks like for a small firm

Two copies, with at least one separated and protected by its own login. Alerts that reach a person. A restore test on the calendar, twice a year at least.

What to do Monday

One afternoon, one folder, one stopwatch.

  1. Find out where your backups go. And who has the login.
  2. Check the last three reports. Look for warnings, not just "success."
  3. Restore one folder and one mailbox. To a different machine. Time it.
  4. Add a second sign-in step to the backup account. Separate from your everyday logins.
  5. Book the next test. Put it on the calendar now.

Backup and recovery is a core part of our managed IT services and cloud services. See our page for professional services firms. And it's one of the four things on the cyber insurance renewal form.

Want proof your backup works?

Hawke Consulting offers a free IT assessment. We look at how your systems are set up today and tell you plainly what we would fix first. No pressure, no jargon.

Book a free IT assessment

General information, not legal advice. Hawke Consulting does not certify or guarantee compliance with any law or standard. Figures come from the sources linked in this article.