Hawke Consulting
Free IT assessment
Menu
Home / Articles / Professional services
Professional servicesBasic5 min readNovember 2026

Cyber insurance renewal: four boxes you'll wish you'd ticked

Page 1 of the form is cheerful. Page 3 asks about multi-factor sign-in, and the honest answer is "mostly, except Dave."

Cyber insurance renewal formPage 3 is the one that mattersMulti-factor sign-inA second step on email, remoteaccess and admin accountsBackupsSeparate, protected and testedEndpoint protectionMore than old-school antivirusPhishing trainingStaff who can spot the bait

Renewal season. The form arrives.

Page 1 is cheerful.

Page 3 asks whether everyone uses multi-factor authentication, and the honest answer is "mostly, except Dave."

The four things carriers keep asking

A February 2026 write-up from broker Hummel Group lists what cyber insurers commonly expect from small businesses. It's one broker's view, and your carrier's form rules, but the four items match what we see.

1. Multi-factor sign-in. Ranked first. Expected for email, remote access, and admin accounts. The article's blunt line: without it, coverage is very hard to get. It also notes that authenticator apps and security keys are stronger than text-message codes.

2. Backups. Separated from your main network, protected, and tested. More on that in your backup is only a backup if you've seen it restore.

3. Endpoint detection and response. Software that blocks or quarantines threats on each computer, not just flags them. Traditional antivirus alone is often not enough.

4. Staff training. Phishing and social engineering awareness, with records.

The "Dave" problem

Most firms are 95% there. Dave's account is the exception: the partner who refuses the second step, the shared mailbox nobody enrolled, the old admin login. Those exceptions are exactly where attackers look, and exactly where an application question gets awkward. Close them before you answer, not after.

Why guessing on the form is the expensive way to fail

If you answer yes and the real answer is "mostly," ask your broker what that can mean for a claim. Better to answer accurately and fix the gap than to find out during a bad week.

Also useful: the FBI says business email compromise cost $3.04 billion in 2025, which is why carriers care so much about email sign-in.

What to do Monday

Before the renewal email arrives.

  1. Pull your current application. Read the security questions as if you were the underwriter.
  2. Check MFA coverage. Email, remote access, and every admin account. Find the Daves.
  3. Test a restore. Pick one folder and one mailbox. Time it.
  4. Ask IT about endpoint protection. Is it detect-and-respond, or just old antivirus?
  5. Run training and keep the records. A one-hour session, signed in, counts.

We help professional services firms answer these questions with evidence. See our page for professional services firms and our cybersecurity services.

Renewal coming up and not sure what you'd answer?

Hawke Consulting offers a free IT assessment. We look at how your systems are set up today and tell you plainly what we would fix first. No pressure, no jargon.

Book a free IT assessment

General information, not legal advice. Hawke Consulting does not certify or guarantee compliance with any law or standard. Figures come from the sources linked in this article. Insurance requirements vary by carrier and policy; check yours with your broker.